About the Theory
Open Research Questions
Phenotypic Dermatology develops by posing questions and testing them experimentally. This page collects questions that remain open for further study: on the skin state, transitions between states, methods and the relationship with clinical practice.
The author’s questions are given with the source; all quotations are our translation from Russian. Questions marked “Editorial question” were formulated when preparing the page and approved by the author. Quoted statements on which questions are based are marked “The author’s position” or “Basis of the question”. Statuses are given only on the basis of the author’s materials; where there is no information, the status is “requires clarification”.
- with the source and page; our translation
- with the source; our translation
- Editorial question
- formulated when preparing the page, approved by the author
- The author’s position Basis of the question
- a quoted statement on which a question is based (our translation)
Characterizing and recording the skin state
Related to the theory:Term “skin state S(x, t)”Principle 1: the subpopulation phenotype as the “unit” of investigationConcept
“This notation is a conceptual model of the skin state. Its components denote groups of characteristics whose completeness and accuracy of experimental determination depend on the research methods used.”
Questions
- Editorial question
What minimal set of characteristics is sufficient to record the state S(x, t) of a selected skin site and to distinguish it from the state of another site at the same time point?
Basis: the author’s notation S(x₁, t) ≠ S(x₂, t) (S11)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
How should the site x and the time point t be recorded in a study protocol so that a record of the state can be unambiguously related to the place and time of taking the biopsy specimen?
Basis: the definitions of x and t (S11)
Status: requires clarification.
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
- “In the future, large-scale use of the cytoimmunogram will make it possible to create a sex- and age-specific register of the skin state in health and disease…” — S8, abstract
Comparability of measurements and reproducibility of results
Related to the theory:Method: comparing two states of a skin siteMethod: skin cytoimmunogram
“Phenotypic Dermatology allows its principles to be developed and refined as new data accumulate, while preserving the integrity of its theoretical basis and the reproducibility of the procedures for assessing the phenotypic state of the skin.”
Questions
- Editorial question
How closely do skin cytoimmunogram results agree when the same sample is examined repeatedly and when neighboring skin sites are examined at the same time point?
Basis: the requirement of reproducible assessment procedures (S3, p. 63)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
Which conditions of taking, processing and storing the biopsy specimen affect the comparability of results?
Basis: in the single case analyzed, cell viability was 99.8% in the native sample and 87.0% after cryopreservation (S8, abstract)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
How can results obtained in different laboratories and with different antibody panels be compared?
Basis: the prospect of standardizing phenotypic analysis (S3, pp. 196–197)
Status: requires clarification.
Status of the direction: In the section “What has been proven?”, the monograph calls Phenotypic Dermatology “a substantiated and reproducible scientific concept” (S3, p. 195). As the author specifies, this assessment is based on the experiments the author has carried out (S14). The questions below concern the reproducibility of individual measurements; their status requires clarification.
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
Recording transitions over time
Related to the theory:Term “transition between skin states”Principle 9: conceptual schemes of states and transitionsMethod: comparing two states of a skin site
“subtraction of multidimensional states is admissible only after the measurable components and the rules for comparing them have been defined. For now, it is more correct to write the transition as: S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁)”
Questions
- Editorial question
Do changes in the phenotypic state of the skin occur continuously?
Basis: the author’s correction of the wording “changes occur continuously” (S12)
Status: As the author specifies, “continuity has not been proven”; the correct wording is that changes “may occur over time” (S12).
- Editorial question
Can a change in the phenotypic state of the skin be recorded before clinically distinguishable signs appear?
Basis: the author’s position: “these changes may occur long before clinically distinguishable signs appear” (S10, S11)
Status: The author’s position; presented on this site as a hypothesis (S10). Verification requires clarification.
- Editorial question
At what intervals should the observation of site x be repeated to distinguish the transition S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁) from the scatter of measurements?
Basis: the notation of the transition (S11) and the method for comparing states
Status: requires clarification.
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
- “to objectively assess the dynamics of a skin disease” — S8, abstract: among the prospects for using the cytoimmunogram
Relationships between cell composition, functions, interactions and tissue organization
Related to the theory:Concept: the model [C, F, I, O]Principle 2: the skin as a dynamic systemTerm “cell subpopulations”Criticism: remark 11 and the author’s response
Questions
- The author’s position
“the phenotypic states of cells can serve as a starting point for the subsequent study of cytokine networks, intercellular interactions and the regulatory mechanisms of the tissue microenvironment”
Source: the author’s response to remark 11 (S1, section “Criticism”)
Comment: In the author’s assessment, “the critic demanded level 2, while at that time I had only managed to build level 1” (ibid.).
- Editorial question
How can the phenotypic data of the skin cytoimmunogram for a skin site be compared with data on cytokine networks, intercellular interactions and the regulatory mechanisms of the tissue microenvironment at the same site?
Basis: the author’s position in the response to remark 11 (S1)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
How do changes in cell composition (C) relate to changes in tissue organization (O) at the same skin site?
Basis: the conceptual model [C, F, I, O] (S12)
Status: requires clarification.
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
- “Integration of Phenotypic Dermatology with single-cell and spatial transcriptomics technologies for spatiotemporal modeling of pathological processes.” — S3, p. 196
Potential and limitations of the skin cytoimmunogram and FIVK
Related to the theory:Method: skin cytoimmunogramMethod: phenotypic index of skin inflammation (FIVK)Patents RU 2 630 607 C1 and RU 2 870 371 C1Article on the skin cytoimmunogram (Medical Immunology (Russia), 2018)Criticism: remark 10 and the author’s response
“the skin cytoimmunogram becomes an instrument for measuring individual components of S(x, t), and FIVK a quantitative indicator of the dynamics of the inflammatory component of the skin state.”
Questions
- Editorial question
Which components of the skin state does the skin cytoimmunogram measure directly, and which characteristics are inferred from phenotypic data?
Basis: the author’s clarification: “distinguish between direct measurements and conclusions about interactions based on phenotypic data”; “the skin cytoimmunogram does not measure all components of this model directly” (S12)
Status: The author states that the skin cytoimmunogram does not measure all components directly (S12). Which characteristics belong to direct measurements requires clarification.
- Editorial question
How well does FIVK, calculated from 11 cell phenotypes, reflect the dynamics of the inflammatory component in repeated measurements at the same skin site?
Basis: FIVK is “a quantitative indicator of the dynamics of the inflammatory component” (S11); 11 phenotypes — patent RU 2 870 371 C1 (P1)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
Can comparable phenotypic data be obtained with less invasive ways of taking material?
Basis: the author’s response to remark 10: “The remark rightly reflects the limitations of the existing technology for obtaining material. At the time the method was developed, the study required obtaining a skin biopsy specimen.” (S1)
Status: The author attributes this limitation “to the way the data are obtained, not to the concept of phenotypic analysis itself” (S1). Research requires clarification.
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
- “Development of artificial intelligence algorithms for the automatic interpretation of skin cytoimmunograms…” — S3, p. 197 (research prospects)
Phenotypic states and clinical diagnoses
Related to the theory:Principle 6: accuracy of skin state diagnosisArticle “Skin State: From Cellular Phenotype to a Mathematical Model”Criticism: remark 12 and the author’s response
“One diagnosis may encompass many phenotypic states of the skin. And, conversely, similar phenotypic states may occur in different diagnoses.”
Questions
- Basis of the question
“the relationships between specific phenotypes of skin cell subpopulations and the clinical signs of diseases have not been established; this knowledge could substantially strengthen the therapeutic capabilities of dermatology with respect to numerous skin diseases, especially immune-mediated ones”
Source: S3, p. 36 (theoretical problems)
Status: The relationship between phenotypes and clinical signs requires further scientific research (the author’s clarification, S14).
- Editorial question
Which specific phenotypes of skin cell subpopulations are associated with the clinical signs of diseases, and by what criteria can this association be tested?
Basis: the theoretical problem formulated by the author (S3, p. 36)
Status: requires clarification.
- The author’s position
“The skin cytoimmunogram does not replace the diagnosis but complements it with objective data on the state of the cellular microenvironment.”
Source: the author’s response to remark 12 (S1, section “Criticism”); the author writes that the critic “formulated one of the main questions to the theory”
- Editorial question
Which data of the skin cytoimmunogram complement the clinical diagnosis, and how can their contribution to the diagnostic decision be assessed?
Basis: the author’s position in the response to remark 12 (S1)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
How much do the phenotypic states of the skin differ between patients with the same clinical diagnosis?
Basis: the author’s position on the relationship between diagnosis and state (S10, S12)
Status: requires clarification.
- Editorial question
By which characteristics can similar phenotypic states occurring in different diagnoses be distinguished?
Basis: ibid.
Status: requires clarification.
Testing the potential to predict and manage transitions
Related to the theory:Principle 13: transition to a new type of dermatologyConcept: research directions
“Diagnosis, prediction and managing transitions are research directions whose potential requires verification.”
Questions
- Editorial question
Which characteristics of the state S(x, t₀) could indicate the direction of the subsequent transition, and how can this be tested in a prospective observation?
Basis: the author’s program “from measuring phenotypes to predicting processes” (S1, “What next?”)
Status: Requires verification (S13).
- Editorial question
Which criteria, set in advance, would allow a prediction of a transition to be considered confirmed or refuted?
Basis: the requirement that a theory be consistent with empirical data (S3, p. 63)
Status: Requires verification (S13).
What data would help to make progress — from the author’s materials
- “From measuring phenotypes to predicting processes, from prediction to managing the skin state.” — S1, section “What next?”
Discuss a question or propose a study
If you are working on one of these questions or see a way to test it, the author invites you to discuss it and work together.
Sources
- S1 — Goltsov S. V. Dermatologiya: ot nablyudeniya k ponimaniyu [Dermatology: from observation to understanding]. goltsovs.ru — the author’s blog, sections “Criticism” (12 remarks and responses) and “What next?” (in Russian). Copy saved on 18 November 2026. Post in the author’s blog (in Russian) (opens in a new tab) (checked 20 November 2026)Criticism and the author’s responses on this site
- S3 — Goltsov S. Fenotipicheskaya dermatologiya [Phenotypic Dermatology]. Tyumen: Izdatel’ S. V. Goltsov, 2026. 208 p. ISBN 978-5-600-04919-2 (in Russian). Page numbers on this page refer to the book. About the monographFull text on the author’s website (in Russian) (opens in a new tab) (checked 20 November 2026)
- S8 — Goltsov S. V., Goltsova E. N., Sukhovey Yu. G., Kostolomova E. G., Pauls V. Yu. Cytoimmunogram of the skin: a new method for objective evaluation of the skin cell subpopulation profile. Medical Immunology (Russia). 2018; 20(3): 373–382. DOI: 10.15789/1563-0625-2018-3-373-382. Journal page (opens in a new tab) (checked 20 November 2026)DOI (opens in a new tab) (checked 20 November 2026)Entry in Publications
- S9 — Goltsov S. V., Goltsova E. N., Sukhovey Yu. G., Kostolomova E. G., Pauls V. Yu. Tsitoimmunogramma kozhi kak sposob otsenki ee immunnogo statusa [Skin cytoimmunogram as a way to assess its immune status]. Kosmetika i meditsina. 2017; (3): 48–50 (in Russian). Text from the author’s copy; no journal page was found online. Entry in Publications
- S10 — Goltsov S. V. Answers to questions on the theory: S(x, t), the difference between the skin state and the diagnosis (18 November 2026, in Russian). Unpublished; kept in the project archive.
- S11 — Goltsov S. V. Explanations of the notation S(x, t): a formal model of the skin state, the notation of a transition, the roles of the skin cytoimmunogram and FIVK (PDF, 18 November 2026, in Russian). Unpublished; kept in the project archive.
- S12 — Goltsov S. V. Scientific review of the article “What is the skin state S(x, t)” (18 November 2026, in Russian). Unpublished; kept in the project archive. The author’s clarifications are reflected in the article on this site. Article “Skin State: From Cellular Phenotype to a Mathematical Model”
- S13 — Goltsov S. V. The concept of Phenotypic Dermatology: the text and the brief for the concept diagram (18 November 2026, in Russian). The text of the concept is published on this site. The concept and diagram on this site
- S14 — Goltsov S. V. Answers to questions R-1–R-7 on the pages “Open Research Questions” and “Publications” (20 November 2026, in Russian). Unpublished; kept in the project archive.
- P1 — Goltsov S. V. Sposob opredeleniya fenotipicheskogo indeksa vospaleniya kozhi [Method for determining the phenotypic index of skin inflammation; our translation]. Patent RU 2 870 371 C1. Application 2026101577 of 22 January 2026; published 21 September 2026, Bulletin No. 27. FIPS register (in Russian) (opens in a new tab) (checked 20 November 2026)Patents and Developments
The author’s questions and quotations are given with the source and page; all quotations are our translation from Russian. Questions marked “Editorial question” were formulated when preparing the page and approved by the author on 20 November 2026 (S14).
Translated from the Russian original. The English translation is awaiting approval by the author.