Skin State: From Cellular Phenotype to a Mathematical Model
How Phenotypic Dermatology explains the spatial diversity of the skin and transitions between its states
A skin state is the set of quantitative and functional characteristics of cell subpopulations, their interactions and tissue organization at a selected skin site at a particular point in time. It is the central concept of Phenotypic Dermatology — the author’s theory by S. V. Goltsov on skin states and transitions between them. The author proposed writing the state as S(x, t), where x is the skin site and t is the time point.
Two key principles of the theory, in the author’s view. First, one diagnosis may encompass many phenotypic states of the skin, and, conversely, similar phenotypic states may occur in different diagnoses. Second, a diagnosis may remain unchanged while the phenotypic state of the skin changes.
What is a skin state, and in which theory did the concept arise?
Phenotypic Dermatology is, first and foremost, the author’s theory of skin states and transitions between them; the skin cytoimmunogram is one of the tools for its experimental implementation. The glossary defines it as a field of dermatology that regards the phenotype of skin cells as the basic unit of analysis of the pathological process.
Unlike classical dermatology, which is based on describing the morphological elements of the rash, Phenotypic Dermatology considers the skin as a dynamic system of cell subpopulations and the immune microenvironment. The classical approach is not abandoned: it is complemented by the study of the cell composition of the skin, cell phenotypes and their interactions.
In the author’s view, Phenotypic Dermatology can be described as “a theory of the spatiotemporal states of the skin and of transitions between them, determined by changes in cell subpopulations, their functions, interactions and tissue organization”.
How can a skin state be written down: what does S(x, t) mean?
S(x, t) is a proposed mathematical notation of the author’s definition of the skin state, not a model that has already been developed and validated. In it, the state is expressed as a function of two variables — space and time.
- S (State) — the skin state, characterized by the set of quantitative and functional characteristics of cell subpopulations, their interactions and tissue organization;
- x (Space) — the specific skin site where the state is studied;
- t (Time) — the specific time point at which this state is determined.
What does this look like in an example?
This is a thought experiment, not a description of a particular patient. Imagine a patient with atopic dermatitis. At the same point in time, the state of the skin on the forearm may differ substantially from the state of the skin on the back. Notation: S(x₁, t) ≠ S(x₂, t), where x₁ and x₂ are two different sites.
At the same skin site, the state may change under the influence of treatment. Notation: S(x, t₀) ≠ S(x, t₁), where t₀ and t₁ are different time points.
What components does the model consist of?
If a skin state is determined not by a single indicator but by a set of cellular characteristics, then, in the author’s view, it is more accurate to represent it as a multidimensional function:
S(x, t) = [C(x, t), F(x, t), I(x, t), O(x, t)]
- C — the quantitative and subpopulation composition of cells;
- F — the functional characteristics of cell subpopulations;
- I — interactions between cells;
- O (organization) — tissue organization; the letter O was chosen so that this component is not confused with time t.
This notation is a conceptual model of the skin state. Its components denote groups of characteristics whose completeness and accuracy of experimental determination depend on the research methods used. It is important to distinguish between the skin state as a biological reality and its description through measurable characteristics.
What makes up a skin state?
A skin state is described through the composition and properties of cell subpopulations, their interactions and tissue organization. Cell subpopulations are groups of skin cells of one type, each of which has a distinctive (specific) functional and molecular cell structure. The subpopulation phenotype is the “unit” that explains the diversity of skin states at the cellular level.
In the first principle of the theory, the skin cell subpopulation phenotype is defined as follows (“it” refers to the subpopulation phenotype): “It is a subpopulation consisting of skin cells of one type and having a distinctive (specific) functional and molecular cell structure.” The set of subpopulations of the skin site studied is a different level of description (the author’s clarification, 20 November 2026). The phenotype is the unit of analysis; what is measured are quantitative and functional characteristics. The phenotypic features studied make it possible to judge individual aspects of the functional state of cells.
In this way, the unit of analysis is no longer a morphological element but the skin cell subpopulation phenotype.
What is a transition between skin states?
A transition between skin states is a change of the skin state over time. It may be accompanied by visible clinical changes. Clinical signs may be one of the observable manifestations of a transition.
A transition is written as S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁); a sequence of transitions at one site as S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁) → S(x, t₂). The author accompanies the notation as a difference, ΔS(x; t₀, t₁) = S(x, t₁) − S(x, t₀), with a caveat: “subtraction of multidimensional states is admissible only after the measurable components and the rules for comparing them have been defined”.
The research question of the theory is how the composition of cell subpopulations, their properties and tissue organization change in the transition from one skin state to another. The monograph proposes conceptual schemes for skin states in statics, for transitions between states (dynamics) and for transitions caused by various types of intervention, followed by the synthesis of these schemes.
How are two states of the same site compared?
- Specify the skin site studied and the time point of observation.
- Describe the cell composition, functional characteristics and tissue organization.
- At a repeat observation, compare the characteristics and describe the transition.
An illustrative example (not a clinical case): one skin site is described at two time points. For each observation, the visible signs and the available tissue data are recorded. The comparison helps to formulate which characteristics of the state have changed.
Why should a skin state not be equated with a diagnosis?
In short, a diagnosis answers the question “What disease does the skin have?”, whereas a phenotypic state answers “What is happening in the skin, and how is it organized?”. A diagnosis classifies a disease. The phenotypic state of the skin characterizes the cellular organization, functions and interactions that determine the state of the skin at a specific point in time.
The concept distinguishes three differences:
- Ontological. A skin state exists as a biological reality, regardless of whether it has been recognized.
- Epistemological. A diagnosis is the result of medical cognition and the classification of a disease.
- Dynamic. A skin state changes over time, whereas a diagnosis may persist through many such changes. It is this difference that opens the way to studying transitions between states.
In notation, this looks as follows: S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁) → S(x, t₂), while the diagnosis D may remain the same: D(t₀) = D(t₁) = D(t₂). This is the second key principle: in the author’s view, a diagnosis may remain unchanged while the phenotypic state of the skin changes. The first principle: one diagnosis may encompass many phenotypic states, and similar phenotypic states may occur in different diagnoses.
The author considers the reverse to be possible as well: a change in diagnosis does not necessarily mean a simultaneous change in the biological state of the skin — sometimes only the understanding of an already existing process changes. In the explanations to the model, the author defines a diagnosis as “a clinical interpretation of the observed state and the history of its changes”.
Phenotypic Dermatology does not abolish nosological diagnosis — that is, diagnosing a specific disease — and does not set cell phenotypes against it: it offers a different level of description of biological reality. A diagnosis makes it possible to classify a disease, while phenotypic analysis makes it possible to study the specific skin state that may exist within that disease. These are complementary ways of knowing. Likewise, the skin cytoimmunogram does not replace the diagnosis but complements it.
“A diagnosis unites what is similar. A phenotypic state makes it possible to distinguish what is individual.” — S. V. Goltsov
In the author’s view, this is where one of the fundamental foundations of Phenotypic Dermatology arises — “a transition from the classification of diseases to the study of skin states and the patterns of their change”. Here the word “transition” means a change of approach, not a transition between skin states.
The author also hypothesizes that changes of state may occur long before clinically distinguishable signs appear. This is a hypothesis that the author assigns to the future of the theory, not a current capability of the method.
How can a skin state be studied?
The skin cytoimmunogram is the presentation of the results of the study, including phenotypes and quantitative indicators; a cell suspension obtained from a biopsy specimen of a selected skin site is examined. In the model of the state, the skin cytoimmunogram is “a tool for measuring individual components of S(x, t)”; it does not directly measure all components of the model. How a skin cytoimmunogram is obtained and how to read its indicators is explained in the article “The Skin Cytoimmunogram: From Cell Suspension to a Characteristic of the Skin State”.
The methodological basis of Phenotypic Dermatology is flow cytometry and the skin cytoimmunogram method. Flow cytometry is a laboratory method used to determine the phenotype of cells by specific markers.
It is important to distinguish between direct measurements and conclusions about cell interactions drawn from phenotypic data.
In the author’s model, the phenotypic index of skin inflammation (FIVK) is a quantitative indicator of the dynamics of the inflammatory component of the skin state. How the index is calculated is explained in the article “FIVK: Calculating and Interpreting the Inflammatory Component of the Skin State”.
At the time the method was developed, the study required obtaining a skin biopsy specimen — a small fragment of skin taken during a biopsy. In the author’s view, this limitation concerns the way the data are obtained, not the concept itself. In the monograph, the author formulates a principle of the theory: the overall connectedness of the relationships between cells determines the structure of the phenotype and provides complete information about the state of the skin fragment within the biopsy, but not of the skin as a whole. This is a principle of the theory, not a description of the method’s capabilities: the skin cytoimmunogram does not directly measure all components of the model.
How well tested is the concept?
The principles of the theory continue to be developed and tested in scientific and clinical research. The notation S(x, t) still remains a proposed conceptual model, not one that has been developed and validated.
A quantitative assessment of cell subpopulations does not exhaust the full variety of processes in the skin. The theory does not regard the phenotype as the end point of research: the phenotypic states of cells can serve as a starting point for studying cytokine networks, intercellular interactions and regulatory mechanisms.
Continue reading
- The Skin Cell Subpopulation Phenotype — the Unit of Investigation — what exactly is distinguished at the cellular level: the cell, the subpopulation, the phenotype and two levels of description.
- The Skin Cytoimmunogram: From Cell Suspension to a Characteristic of the Skin State — how a skin cytoimmunogram is obtained, how the report form is structured and how to read its numbers.
- FIVK: Calculating and Interpreting the Inflammatory Component of the Skin State — how the index is calculated from 11 phenotypes and how its value should be understood.
Questions and answers
What is a skin state?
In Phenotypic Dermatology — the author’s theory by S. V. Goltsov on skin states and transitions between them — a skin state means the set of quantitative and functional characteristics of cell subpopulations, their interactions and tissue organization at a selected skin site at a particular point in time.
What does the notation S(x, t) mean?
S(x, t) is a proposed mathematical notation of the author’s definition of the skin state, not a model that has already been developed and validated. In it, the state is expressed as a function of two variables — space and time: S (State) is the skin state, x (Space) is the specific skin site where the state is studied, and t (Time) is the specific time point at which this state is determined.
What components does the S(x, t) model consist of?
In the author’s view, if a skin state is determined not by a single indicator but by a set of cellular characteristics, it is more accurate to represent it as a multidimensional function: S(x, t) = [C(x, t), F(x, t), I(x, t), O(x, t)]. C is the quantitative and subpopulation composition of cells, F is the functional characteristics of cell subpopulations, I is interactions between cells, and O (organization) is tissue organization. This notation is a conceptual model of the skin state; its components denote groups of characteristics whose completeness and accuracy of experimental determination depend on the research methods used.
Why does the theory regard the phenotype as the unit of analysis?
In Phenotypic Dermatology, the subpopulation phenotype is the “unit” that explains the diversity of skin states at the cellular level. According to the first principle of the theory, it is a subpopulation consisting of skin cells of one type and having a distinctive (specific) functional and molecular cell structure. The phenotype is the unit of analysis; what is measured are quantitative and functional characteristics. In this way, the unit of analysis is no longer a morphological element but the skin cell subpopulation phenotype.
What is a transition between skin states?
A transition between skin states is a change of the skin state over time. It may be accompanied by visible clinical changes; clinical signs may be one of the observable manifestations of a transition. The author writes a transition as S(x, t₀) → S(x, t₁).
How does a skin state differ from a diagnosis?
In the author’s words, a diagnosis answers the question “What disease does the skin have?”, whereas a phenotypic state answers “What is happening in the skin, and how is it organized?”. A diagnosis classifies a disease. The phenotypic state of the skin characterizes the cellular organization, functions and interactions that determine the state of the skin at a specific point in time. Phenotypic Dermatology does not abolish nosological diagnosis (diagnosing a specific disease): diagnosis and phenotypic analysis are complementary ways of knowing. The author puts it this way: “A diagnosis unites what is similar. A phenotypic state makes it possible to distinguish what is individual.”
Can a diagnosis stay the same when the skin state changes?
In the author’s view, yes: a diagnosis may remain unchanged while the phenotypic state of the skin changes. The author distinguishes three differences between the skin state and the diagnosis; one of them is dynamic: a skin state changes over time, whereas a diagnosis may persist through many such changes. In addition, one diagnosis may encompass many phenotypic states of the skin, and similar phenotypic states may occur in different diagnoses.
Has the theory of Phenotypic Dermatology been proven?
According to the author, the principles of the theory continue to be developed and tested in scientific and clinical research. The notation S(x, t) still remains a proposed conceptual model, not one that has been developed and validated.
Sources
Published sources
- Goltsov S. V. Sposob opredeleniya fenotipicheskogo indeksa vospaleniya kozhi [Method for determining the phenotypic index of skin inflammation; our translation]. Patent RU 2 870 371 C1, IPC G01N 33/53. Application 2026101577 of 22.01.2026; published 21.09.2026, Bull. No. 27 (in Russian). — description of the invention: the full name of the index (FIVK) · Patents · Original
- Prototype of the website “Phenotypic Dermatology — a theory of skin states” (structure and wording of the sections; in Russian). — block “Key idea”; “The theory in brief”; sections “Research”, “Methods” (“How to compare states”), “Application” (“Observation over time”) · Original
- Goltsov S. Fenotipicheskaya dermatologiya [Phenotypic Dermatology]. Tyumen: Publisher S. V. Goltsov, 2026. 208 p. ISBN 978-5-600-04919-2 (in Russian). — p. 7 — introductory text; p. 60 — “Principles of the theory”, principles 1 and 2; p. 61 — “Principles of the theory” · About the monograph · Original
- Goltsov S. V. Dermatologiya: ot nablyudeniya k ponimaniyu [Dermatology: from observation to understanding]. The author’s blog, goltsovs.ru (in Russian). — sections “What is Phenotypic Dermatology?”, “Five key principles”, “What is the theory based on?”, “Frequently asked questions”, “Criticism” (remarks 10–12) · Original
- Goltsov S. V., Goltsova E. N., Sukhovey Yu. G., Kostolomova E. G., Pauls V. Yu. Tsitoimmunogramma kozhi kak sposob otsenki ee immunnogo statusa [Skin cytoimmunogram as a way to assess its immune status]. Kosmetika i meditsina [Cosmetics and Medicine]. 2017; (3): 48–50 (in Russian). — steps for obtaining a skin cytoimmunogram · Entry in Publications
The author’s clarifications and materials
- Goltsov S. V. Explanations of the notation S(x, t): a formal model of the skin state, notation of a transition, the role of the skin cytoimmunogram and FIVK, definition of diagnosis (author’s statement, PDF, 2026-11-18; in Russian). — p. 1 — formulas for the example; pp. 1–2 — multidimensional function; p. 2 — notation of a transition, the skin cytoimmunogram, FIVK, definition of diagnosis
- Goltsov S. V. Scientific review of the article “What is the skin state S(x, t)” (author’s statement, 2026-11-18; in Russian). — items 1–4 and 6; concluding section
- Goltsov S. V. Answers to questions on the theory: S(x, t), the difference between the skin state and the diagnosis, wording from the monograph (author’s statement, 2026-11-18; in Russian). — item 2 “Difference between the skin state and the diagnosis”; item 4 “The notation S(x, t)”
This material is for information only and does not replace a consultation with a doctor.